Judges

A panel of six expert critics scores the concept.

3 min read

All guides

What this step does

Judges puts your concept in front of a panel of six expert critics, each scoring from their own discipline, and combines them into a single verdict. It's an honest read on where the design is strong and where it's exposed.

What you do here

  1. 1Read each judge's scorecard and reasoning.
  2. 2Note the recurring weaknesses: they're your revision list.
  3. 3Go back and improve, then re-judge to see the verdict move.
The Judges step, an expert critic's scorecard with a numeric score and a combined verdict
Six expert scorecards and a combined verdict.